{"schema":"mouseion.pinakes/1","id":"APORIA-0001","kind":"question","title":"What is the meaning of life, the universe, and everything in it?","version":{"basis":"PINNED_CATALOGUE","corpus_sha256":"6cec7da7a87e35c8018933235b4a1938e26c5c6489d1db2c3601a77605c2ae84"},"folio_ids":["GVF-001"],"statement":"What is the meaning of life, the universe, and everything in it?\n\nMultiple philosophical traditions distinguish meaning in individual lives, possible purpose of humanity, and the significance of existence; there is no institutionally adopted final answer.\n\nOpen: Whether meaning is discovered or made, universal or personal, and how empirical knowledge relates to values and purpose.","source_ids":[],"epistemic":{"canonical_status":"PERPETUAL_OPEN_DISCUSSION","execution":"NOT_APPLICABLE","index_certifies_truth":false,"limitations":"No calculation, popularity vote or scientific experiment alone establishes one universal normative answer; preserve pluralism. “42” is a Douglas Adams literary joke, not evidence."},"bibliography":{"creators":[],"date":null,"language":"und","identifiers":[],"subjects":[],"format":null,"original_url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/life-meaning/"},"permissions":{"owner_read":true,"owner_private_archive":false,"visitor_metadata":true,"public_content_redistribution":false,"external_provider_content_transfer":false,"basis":"Exact HCR public release manifest under ENG-011; linked content rights remain separate"},"provenance":{"basis":"HCR_AUTHORED_PUBLIC_APORIA","corpus_sha256":"6cec7da7a87e35c8018933235b4a1938e26c5c6489d1db2c3601a77605c2ae84","author":"HCR Digital Works","as_of":"2026-10-15"},"question":{"domain":"Meaning & Existence","progress":"Rigorous, accessible comparisons of competing interpretations; revised questions and new perspectives, not a fabricated single verdict.","source_urls":["https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/life-meaning/","https://news.mit.edu/2019/answer-life-universe-and-everything-sum-three-cubes-mathematics-0910"],"answer_status":"NO_FINAL_ANSWER_CLAIMED","reading_journey_url":"/collection/journeys/APORIA-0001.html","folio_binding_basis":"Founding publication/navigation binding only; non-evidential and not a grant or subject-matter support claim.","relationship_review":{"disposition":"RETYPE","approved_on":"2026-10-18","authority":"Hunter instruction to implement the accepted Steward refinements","review":"MOUSEION-STEW-CUR-001-HQ-DEC-01","original_relationship":{"id":"REL:f3fb473ac669d08eda35d5d2","source":"APORIA-0001","predicate":"addresses_investigation","target":"GVF-001","basis":"Curated public question; thematic navigation, not a permission or scientific result","semantic_support_verified":false},"replacement_id":"REL:bb0d9c50a050b6c264db6996","history_url":"/collection/journeys/APORIA-0001-link-history.json","note":"The original deliberate navigation convention is preserved here and in the accepted r2 release. Its false semantic-support flag was a limit, not evidence of data corruption."}}}